 |

Learning to Compete
How Companies Become World Class
Research by Rogelio Oliva
Volume 4, Number 3
Beginning with Chile more than
twenty years ago, Latin America has
experienced a wrenching yet exciting
transformation of its predominantly
inward-looking, state-driven
economies to a robust acceptance and
practice of open-market principles.
Structural reforms in trade, finance,
labor, taxes, and privatization have
created unprecedented opportunities
for firms of all sizes and varieties to
compete in larger markets than ever
before.
In the process, a handful of global organizations have
risen to replace formerly state-owned enterprises,
while scores of previously "protected" firms have
transformed themselves into highly competitive
organizations.
Although a considerable body of research has traced
the macroeconomic reforms of these emerging
economies, little post-reform evaluation, other than
isolated case studies, had occurred at the firm level
before HBS assistant professor Rogelio Oliva and
Fernando F. Suarez began to study the effects of
these changes three years ago when both were on
the faculty of Chile's Universidad Adolfo Ibáñez.
Recently published as an HBS working paper titled
"The Transformation of Firms in Post-Reform
Emerging Economies," their preliminary findings
suggest that the profound economic metamorphoses
taking place in Latin America's emerging economies
have imposed dramatic changes on the competitive
environment, compelling firms to develop new
strategies and capabilities in order to compete.
Moreover, the authors contend, the transformational
process hypothesized in their study may also be
applicable to companies in newly emerging
economies outside Latin America, such as Eastern
Europe, northern Africa, China, and India.
Setting out on their research, Oliva and Suarez were
both intrigued by the fact that while many Latin
American firms simply folded under the pressure of
intensified competition, others-such as Mexico's
Hylsamex and Argentina's Siderca, both major
manufacturers of steel-emerged to become
world-class players. They wanted to know what
these companies had done to transform themselves
so successfully.
Selecting a group of fourteen firms of various sizes
from three industries (energy, steel, and
food/beverages) in four countries (Argentina, Brazil,
Chile, and Mexico), the two scholars set about to
find answers through field research. Speaking to
senior executives, Oliva and Suarez discovered that
all the organizations they studied responded to their
post-reform competitive environments in roughly
four stages:
- Stage I: Turnaround and Catch-up.
Recognizing that their efficiency and quality
levels were far below those of world- class
competitors, the firms initiated action plans to
measure the gap and catch up. Often such
change involved significant modifications in the
structure, size, scope, and culture of the
organization.
- Stage II: Expansion. Realizing that growth
was imperative for survival against larger
rivals, the companies expanded their
operations significantly, usually joining with
related businesses in the local market or even
in other countries.
- Stage III: Acquisition of New Capabilities.
Becoming increasingly sophisticated as they
competed with larger foreign rivals, the firms
developed new capabilities in areas such as
customer service, technological innovation,
and brand management.
- Stage IV: Quest for Industry Leadership.
Having completed the previous stages, the
companies concentrated on becoming
dominant in a particular industry. As a result,
some were able to compete with the best of
their global competitors; others became
top-class niche players in the region.
According to Oliva and Suarez, YPF, Argentina's
formerly state-owned oil company, is one example
of a company's transformation following economic
reform. Unlike Chile, which modified its economic
policies gradually under the Pinochet regime,
Argentina imposed massive reforms in privatization,
capital markets, trade tariffs, and taxation virtually
overnight in 1991, sending shock waves throughout
its economy. For YPF, at the time heavily diversified
in cinemas, airlines, hotels, and restaurants in
addition to energy, the first order of business was to
contain costs, including a reduction in its workforce
from 50,000 to 5,500 employees and the sale of all
of its non-oil-related assets. By the end of this
eighteen-month phase, two-thirds of the company
was sold.
In Stage II, YPF took advantage of expansion
opportunities by entering the Chilean market through
its downstream operations and by acquiring a
company in the U.S. market, thereby positioning
itself as a global player in oil. By the time it reached
Stage III, YPF had developed several innovative
capabilities, including "dual ladder" promotion
systems to nurture technological talent within the
organization. By 1999, YPF had turned itself into a
competitive company in the world market-a hot
property that was recently bought by Repsol, the
largest energy consortium in Spain.
Once they arrive at the final stage of their
transformation-a level achieved by only a few Latin
American companies so far-firms "increasingly act
and look like world leaders in their respective
industries," sometimes even taking "bold steps that
surprise their 'first world' counterparts," Oliva and
Suarez write in their working paper. For example,
they point out, when Cemex, the giant Mexican
cement maker, bought the largest cement company
in Spain, it was evident that a once nationally
focused enterprise was ready to go head-to-head
with leading corporations in Europe and the rest of
the developed world.
Because they developed their initial analysis from a
small sample, Oliva and Suarez, who is now at the
London Business School, plan to survey 250 Latin
American firms in various industries to test the
validity of their findings. "Above all," they say, "we
want to confirm the existence of the various stages of
competitive transformation. Future research will also
help us define the timing of each stage more
precisely as we try to determine the extent of the
challenges that firms in these post-reform emerging
economies face."
Return to top
by Nancy O. Perry
|
|